
The newly-established committee to evaluate AI’s impact at Pomona College opened focus groups to the entire student body on Nov. 18. In the weeks prior, the committee had sent individual invitations to certain students to join focus groups, drawing criticism from some community members.
The committee, officially dubbed “the Ad-hoc Committee on Pomona and Artificial Intelligence,” will aim to guide Pomona’s response to the proliferation of AI in the classroom and beyond, according to a Pomona webpage.
“We are called to respond ethically, and to make sure that any uses of AI on our campus have a positive effect on learning, creativity, and discovery,” the committee’s webpage, located on Pomona’s website, reads.
On Nov. 18, committee members and professors Alana Felton, Mark Andrejevic and Travis Brown sent an email to Pomona students inviting them to participate in one of nine hour-long focus groups. Each session is limited to 10 participants, and committee members said that notes collected during the discussions would be anonymized.
“Your input will inform how Pomona College moves forward regarding AI in the future,” the email read.
The announcement came after Felton, Andrejevic and Brown invited individual students earlier this month to join focus groups.
The individual offers prompted questions from some students, including members of Associated Students of Pomona College (ASPC), about how and why certain students were being recruited.
Tendo Lumala PO ’28, ASPC vice president of academic affairs, said he first learned about the committee’s focus groups after Cloud Morgan Clark PO ’30 contacted him to ask whether an unexpected invitation to join the focus group was associated with ASPC.
Morgan Clark, who received one of the initial invitations and is also a writer and photographer at TSL, said the Nov. 5 email identified them in particular as being a strong candidate for the committee.
“You were recommended by faculty and staff on campus as someone who has exhibited thoughtfulness and leadership potential,” the email read.
Morgan Clark said they had previously heard about the committee from Andrejevic, one of their professors, and later asked him about the selection process. According to Morgan Clark, Andrejevic explained that sponsor groups, which help first-year students transition to Pomona, played a role in identifying participants.
Lumala similarly questioned the absence of students from the committee’s formal membership.
“There are no students on the AI committee,” Lumala said. “If you want to create a transparent process where students are fully engaged from the start, you need to have students.”
In a joint written statement to TSL on Nov. 12, Andrejevic, Brown and Felton elaborated on their objectives and work thus far.
“We have just begun, and our charge is not to create policy but to gather information,” the members wrote.
While Morgan Clark called the committee’s extension of invites to focus groups for all Pomona students “a step in the right direction,” they said they hoped the committee would create additional opportunities for students to engage in conversations about AI, such as through town halls.
According to its Pomona webpage, the committee will submit a report by March 12, 2027, with their evaluation of AI at Pomona and how it could influence learning and research at the college.
In their statement to TSL, Felton, Andrejevic and Brown said the committee’s preliminary discussions included identifying the pressures that might lead students to use AI for their coursework and uncovering whether AI has led to declines in teaching assistant (TA) sessions and office hour attendance.
“We are very interested in learning what uses of the technology members of our community think are appropriate or not appropriate for a liberal arts college,” the members wrote.
To engage students, the trio of committee members told TSL they contacted sponsor groups, mentors, TAs and participants in the Summer Undergraduate Research Program, as well as reaching out to ASPC to hold a focus group with its members.
They added in the Nov. 12 statement that they wanted to “[send] out a general invitation to students to participate in lunch meetings with members of the sub-commmittee,” but did not explicitly label these as focus groups.
Beyond the recruitment process, Lumala questioned the college’s communication to students regarding opportunities to participate in discussions on AI use. Although Pomona published information about the committee online, Lumala said he had not seen a campus-wide announcement detailing how students could become involved prior to their campus-wide email on Nov. 18.
Lumala said he first learned about the committee during office hours with Pomona President G. Gabrielle Starr following fall convocation, where Starr told him that the ad-hoc committee was being established and that a call for faculty applications had already been distributed.
Andrejevic, Brown and Felton said that the Faculty Executive Committee solicited nominations before selecting faculty members based on their interests and experience with AI, and that administrative members were selected “according to similar principles and experience.”
“In an era when there is pressure to focus on outputs rather than process and on speed rather than depth, a liberal arts education is positioned to respond by providing students with the depth and quality of knowledge, thought and communication.”
Lumala suggested that Pomona instead have the AI ad-hoc committee mimic in structure existing faculty committees that already include student representatives, especially since student participation would inform institutional discussions with direct impacts on their academic experiences.
“The model of inclusive representation and shared governance already exists at the college,” Lumala said. “Having students in the room informs discussions heavily because you’re hearing the student perspective.”
As the committee continues to gather information in the coming months, Felton, Andrejevic and Brown said it will continue to emphasize the importance of preserving Pomona’s educational mission while examining AI’s growing influence.
“In an era when there is pressure to focus on outputs rather than process and on speed rather than depth, a liberal arts education is positioned to respond by providing students with the depth and quality of knowledge, thought and communication,” the members wrote.
Facebook Comments