OPINION: The cost of acceptance: What your tuition actually buys

(Shixiao Yu • The Student Life)

We’ve all heard the expression “it’s a small world.” We often say this after discovering an unexpected connection, pausing for a second to steal a moment and appreciate life’s little Easter eggs. But we hardly give the expression a second thought. How much meaning can a four-word colloquialism even have? 

As students of the 6,000-person 5C community, and of our even tinier individual liberal arts schools within it (ranging from 891 to 1,586 people each), a small world rings true to us in a literal sense. The academic universe we are in is truly small, and for many of us, that intimate experience is what drew us to Claremont in the first place.

But the size of our schools in and of itself is not the small world we need to be wary of. As elite as the colleges are, the universe held within them is even harder to get into. A world within a world creates an invisible divide throughout the colleges’ so-called small world, one that boils down to a network of private boarding schools, expensive summer camps and summer home neighborhoods shared by America’s elite. The surprising connections linking privileged people should really come as no surprise at all, because the 1% is not that big. This ‘bubble’ does not begin or end with colleges; it extends from the zip codes of the hospitals where we were born to the zip codes of the plots of land our bodies will one day be lowered into. 

Our small world is the natural consequence of an elitist society — so why is it met with ignorant awe? It’s time we stop accepting Claremont’s bubble of wealth and its impact on our student body as normal. At the same time, we must also recognize the true power of the 5C bubble we are all in, regardless of background. No matter where we come from, we can appreciate the opportunities, networks and multi-billion-dollar endowment we have access to by virtue of being at these schools, and recognize our potential to make change. We all have something different to gain from embracing the world’s true size. 

The first and most obvious victims of these elite small circles are, of course, those it excludes: everyone for whom the bubble isn’t big enough. The small world excludes middle- and working-class students from prestigious universities and social networks, but it also has an impact far greater than keeping any individual outside its gates. The cocoons of wealth and privilege it creates produces future leaders poised to maintain this tradition of exclusion. We are increasingly left to count on the benevolence of congresspeople, CEOs and Wall Street bankers with endless power over our lives, whose only idea of actual class struggle comes from theory they read in pursuit of their Ivy League educations. When the rich only broker power among each other, they guarantee that the decisions steering our country are left to nepotistic children who are simply aloof to the problems of common people. 

We don’t need data to tell us that exposure to diverse socioeconomic perspectives makes us grow as people. Although these numbers and studies do exist, our first-hand experiences are far more compelling. Depending on your background and who you surround yourself with, you’ve likely experienced or witnessed a fair deal of ignorance at the 5Cs, ranging from someone being inconsiderate about the cost of an expensive trip to denigrating community colleges. Maybe you’ve seen or heard these slights without even noticing. Maybe you’ve even spoken or affirmed them yourself. No higher-ed institution is above ignorance and no one is above making mistakes, and this isn’t about ostracizing those who do. But I optimistically hope that we, as 5C students, have more empathy and intelligence than most to face and learn from the mistakes we make, and to realize why it matters more when we make them. With our privilege comes power. We must not let this privilege blind us, and we must move beyond the comfort of our own special ‘small world’ of theory, hypotheticals and social media infographics to wield our power for good in the real world. 

What’s cruelly ironic about the exclusivity of our elitist network is how capable our educational institutions actually are at helping the very people they exclude. Some colleges at the consortium have no problem providing their students with social mobility. In fact, they are among the most capable in the world at doing so. 

A 2017 “Mobility Report Card” study that aggregated data across 30 million students over 14 years shows Claremont McKenna College and Harvey Mudd College as leading the nation in lifting students from the bottom quintile of America’s socioeconomic ladder to the top, with CMC placed as No. 1 in moving students from the bottom 20% of wealth to the top 1%. That trend has remained relatively steady for both institutions, with the median salary of 2025 graduates at $86,000 for CMC students and $124,999 for HMC students. Pomona, Scripps College and Pitzer College were not included in the report. 

A Vox article titled “These colleges are better than Harvard at making poor kids rich,” published following the 2017 study, notes that the problem for colleges and similar schools is the access rate — how many “poor kids” they admit in the first place. That problem remains — once you’re here, doors open, but the difficulty is getting here in the first place. The CMC student body, in particular, is increasingly dissatisfied with this dynamic, especially given the recent record low in admissions for low-income students. Student organizing efforts such as the recent forum on the subject at CMC should model how the other four colleges can address this shortcoming. 

However, variability also exists within Claremont: When we view social mobility as a metric of social justice, the numbers send an especially bad message for Pitzer and Scripps, the only two 5Cs with need-aware admissions policies. For Pitzer in particular, as a school purporting to be centered on social responsibility, its higher share of students from the top 1% than the bottom 60% speaks to a larger issue about who gets to be socially responsible in the first place.

Yet, the least-acknowledged victims of this small-world institutional failure are arguably the rich kids living in a small world made for them. While most of us probably have a natural — and understandable — hesitation to feel any kind of pity for the most privileged among us, we can still gain not only valuable but strategic insight by considering what this status quo costs them. Rather than appealing to empathy, perhaps we can incentivize those in power to support progressive approaches by convincing them it’d positively affect their most important concern: themselves. What spoils the spoiled, in this case, is extremely simple. Living in cocoons of comfort and homogeneous echo chambers costs the elite and their children crucial critical-thinking skills and creativity. As clichè as the message sounds, it is still vital that we don’t take diversity for granted. That means understanding not only that less privileged individuals need access to more privileged spaces, but that exposure to different socioeconomic perspectives benefits everyone. 

Until we begin to face some uncomfortable truths, the world will remain small. Power and wealth might be concentrated in the hands of the few, but they affect all of us disproportionately. No matter who you were before you came to the consortium, you will leave not only with a world-class education, but also with access to inconceivably exclusive networks of power and influence, and at least semi-fluent in the language of wealth. The common access and likelihood of success we share can help us open the door wider for those behind us.

If you find your world in Claremont to be especially small, dare to make it bigger. Pop your bubble. Don’t be afraid to make others uncomfortable for celebrating this exclusion, and don’t be afraid to challenge it with inclusion. But even if it feels like you’re on the outside, remember that once you leave this place, you won’t be. We are all going to walk away from here with incredible connections. Fair or not that we have these, it’s up to us what kind of good we do with them. 

Raymond Hildreth PZ ’29 is off all social media and remains brain-rotted and vain by natural disposition.

Facebook Comments

Facebook Comments