CMC admits historically low percentage of students on financial aid, lags behind peers in financial aid support

(Evelyn Hao • The Student Life)

Claremont McKenna College admitted its lowest percentage of students on need-based financial aid last spring in more than 12 years. The statistic is part of a broader trend in data published by CMC that indicates the college is decreasing its financial aid coverage and lagging behind its peer institutions in financial aid investment.

Since CMC began reporting its enrollment, admissions and financial aid data as part of the Common Data Set initiative in the 2012-2013 academic year, the percentage of CMC students awarded need-based financial aid has ranged from 38% to 43%. 

But after four consecutive years of a steadily declining percentage of students receiving need-based financial aid, CMC reported an all-time minimum of 37.6% last year. A promotional pamphlet in CMC’s Office of Admissions said 33% of this year’s first-year class received need-based financial aid.

Anthony Northington CM ’29 said he expected his out-of-pocket tuition expenses to decrease substantially this academic year, as his mother recently stopped working. Instead, when he talked to CMC’s office of financial aid in March, Northington said staff told him his FAFSA score — which was previously at -1,500, indicating the highest possible level of financial need — had increased, meaning he no longer qualified for the Federal Pell Grant, a need-based grant for undergraduate students. 

“Even though my mom stopped working, my [score] went up, so they were like, ‘We can’t give you as much money,’” Northington said. “I had to appeal, appeal, appeal.”

Northington appealed his financial aid package three times this summer because he said the initial amount he was set to pay was “way more” than what he paid the previous year. While CMC eventually reduced Northington’s tuition costs, Northington — who pays his entire tuition himself — said he still had to pay more this year than last.

He said while staff at the financial aid office are very cooperative, their ability to support students is sometimes inadequate.

“The staff themselves are great,” Northington said. “But the resources they have to ensure that students are better represented in their packages to be able to go to school here [paying] a monetary amount that’s appropriate is not necessarily the best.”

Alex Boekelheide, CMC associate vice president of strategic communications and marketing, acknowledged in an email to TSL that fewer students overall are receiving need-based financial aid, but said the depth of support for students who demonstrate need has not changed.

“While CMC has seen a decline in the percentage of students receiving need-based financial aid in recent years, there has not been a decline in the level of financial aid provided to students who do have need,” Boekelheide wrote.

Although CMC’s cost of attendance has increased by 26% over the past five years, the average need-based financial aid package per student has only risen by 13%, according to CMC’s Common Data Set.

Hailey Stuben CM ’27 said that because her family works in agriculture, which has more variable income than a typical salaried job, her financial aid package from CMC has “fluctuated a lot” year-to-year. She said she has had to negotiate her package “every single year” with the financial aid office.

“Coming into my [first] year, I was able to appeal and get a substantial increase in my financial aid that made CMC a much more viable option,” Stuben said. “But several of the other years, it was really challenging to get across the position of my family and the ways that the assets for agriculture that my family has to deal with specifically work.”

Max Johnson CM ’27, who is also on need-based financial aid, said before coming to CMC, he did not expect his financial aid package to change each year. 

“I don’t think the information is spread enough to incoming students that [your financial package] really is subject to change,” Johnson said.

(Tahi Wilton Geary and Evelyn Hao • The Student Life)

Since 2022, CMC’s net tuition revenue increased by 23.5%, while the college’s financial aid spending only increased by 7.7%. Praise Okodogbe CM ’27 said she found the statistic shocking. 

“If they’re going to raise the price of tuition, they at least should raise the price of financial aid,” Okodogbe said.

As a QuestBridge scholar, Okodogbe said she expected her full-ride scholarship to cover all her expenses for her four years at CMC. But she said she has had to take out multiple loans to cover additional fees like student health insurance, and her sister had to pay her fees for the upcoming semester because her parents were unable to do so.

“I was promised a full ride and I’m paying loans,” Okodogbe said. “The goal [of QuestBridge] was to not worry about that.”

Okodogbe said when she worked as an admissions outreach assistant to help recruit the class of 2030, most of the students who did not choose to attend CMC cited financial aid as the primary reason.

“They were getting more financial aid from other schools, and that was a big factor in why people didn’t choose CMC,” she said.

Common Data Set figures also indicate that CMC lags behind its peer institutions regarding financial aid. Compared to the other top 10 colleges ranked by U.S. News & World Report in 2025 — including Williams College, Amherst College, Swarthmore College and Pomona College and excluding the military academies — the average percentage of the other institutions’ expenses spent on financial aid was 26.2%, according to individual college data from fiscal year 2024. CMC, on the other hand, spent 17.8% of its expenses on financial aid, the lowest percentage spent of the entire group.

Compared to the other Claremont Colleges, CMC still spends the lowest percentage of their expenses on financial aid, with the other 4Cs spending an average 23.8% of their expenses on financial aid.

CMC’s financial aid package coverage has also worsened compared to other top liberal arts institutions. In the 2022-2023 academic year, CMC’s average financial aid package covered 80.64% of the total cost of attendance, which fell roughly in line with its peers. In the 2025-2026 academic year, however, the average package covered just 70.8% of the total cost, making the college drop below its peer institutions in terms of coverage.

Johnson said CMC’s declining financial aid support contradicts its founding purpose to produce leaders through a liberal arts education.

“When I see a statistic like that, it makes me think of all of the other potential leaders in this world that we could have cultivated that didn’t get this chance due to rising costs,” Johnson said.

CMC’s current mission continues to emphasize leadership principles, emphasizing a goal to “prepare students for thoughtful and productive lives and responsible leadership.”

 

Mia Newquist CM ’27 said CMC failing to support students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds is “antithetical” to its mission of developing leaders, both for the underrepresented students themselves and all CMC students.

“I don’t think it’s a good mission if it’s half-assed,” Newquist said. “The best leaders of this world are those who know how to learn amongst people that are different from them.” 

Boekelheide said CMC is taking steps to address the decline in the percentage of students admitted on need-based financial aid.

“We are evaluating the factors behind the recent decline,” he said. “This review will inform our ongoing efforts to ensure that qualified students have access to a CMC education regardless of financial need.”

Stuben said CMC should recognize the financial struggles of current students alongside implementing measures to reduce barriers for future low- and middle-income students to attend CMC.

She said one method could include covering the tuition for any student whose family makes under a certain annual income. Newquist echoed Stuben’s sentiment, citing Swarthmore’s recent commitment to cover the cost of tuition for students whose families make $200,000 per year or less.

“[A similar commitment] would do wonders for showing prospective students that they would be really supported at CMC,” Stuben said. “[It] is a really impressive show of faith for being able to get students from underrepresented communities, both racial and socioeconomic, to have access to an education like CMC.”

Nataly Sanfiel CM ’29, who was matched with CMC through QuestBridge, said given CMC’s significant endowment and strong financial resources, the college’s declining financial aid support is “not a resource issue.”

“It’s a priority issue,” she said. “My happiness shouldn’t be contingent on the amount I pay for school — it shouldn’t be this big stressor [at] a school like CMC.”

Editor’s note: “Military academies” originally read “naval academies.”

Facebook Comments

Facebook Comments