Site icon The Student Life

Students raise concerns over lack of music diversity at 5C parties

A DJ set in with a hand spinning a DJ jog wheel
Student leaders and campus DJs are discussing how to navigate broadening party playlists for major social events. (Penelope Link • The Student Life)

Students raised concerns about a lack of diverse music being played during social events to the Associated Students of Claremont McKenna College (ASCMC) one month ago, prompting student leaders and campus DJs to discuss how to navigate broadening party playlists for major social events like CMC’s upcoming Monte Carlo, set for Saturday, Nov. 21.

At an ASCMC Executive Board meeting on Oct. 25, Diversity and Inclusion Chair Betsaida Quevedo CM ’27 shared that a student raised a concern to her two days prior about a lack of diverse music played at 5C parties.

“Most of the things you hear are house [music] or EDM and not a representation of different genres from different people from different backgrounds,” Quevedo said in an interview with TSL.

Anthony Northington CM ’29, ASCMC’s director of event operations, said music diversity is an important consideration in his work and something he is actively working to improve. 

“[ASCMC’s] music selection has definitely been more diverse than in past years,” Northington said. “We’re trying to wean off of the excessive utilization of EDM or music that doesn’t have lyrics in it, and therefore, I wouldn’t necessarily say that it is something that’s ongoing or an institutional issue.”

Isalena Amador PZ ’29 began to DJ in her junior year of high school and currently experiments with electronic music and Neoperreo, a reggaeton blend. She said she has played a lot of Afro-Latinidad music at smaller 5C functions this year, including at the recent “Noche de Travesuras” event hosted by Hispanic and Latine student groups ¡Mi Gente! and Amor y Apoyo on Nov. 14. 

Amador said it’s not smaller events, but the “main parties,” which often lack diverse music.

“There are places where there’s diversity in music, I just don’t think necessarily that people always like that, because they might just want a party where they can sing the words to every song,” Amador said.

Northington said ASCMC events staff has been paying attention to the DJs and types of music being played at smaller events, like those hosted by affinity groups.

“The events team at ASCMC are now taking notes from clubs like ¡Mi Gente! and some of the DJs [they] used for [their] party this past weekend,” Northington said, referring to “Noche de Travesuras.” “We’re actually thinking of using them for Monte Carlo — we’ve reached out to them.”

Gabe Buyuklyu CM ’28 is one of the presidents of Table Manners, a 5C student-run DJ collective that provides workshops for novice DJs and organizes social events across the consortium. Buyuklyu said the primary issue with playing more diverse music is that many attendees will not have been introduced to it before, and thus might not enjoy it at first exposure. 

“It’s hard to satisfy everyone because everyone has different music tastes,” Buyuklyu said.

He said organizers often grapple with drawing a good crowd and introducing them to a range of great music.

“If people that are willing to listen to new music are going to our parties, I think that’s going to introduce other people as well to this diversity of music,” Buyuklyu said. “We’re looking to attract the right crowd and have that crowd stay with us for the whole night, and that kind of works as a magnet — the more people we have, and the more people are enjoying the music and the diversity of the genres being played, the more people are going to be attracted to that [event].” 

Matteo Marques PO ’29 is a DJ from Miami and grew up going to festivals and raves. He said a large part of being a paid DJ at 5C parties is playing music that crowds will predictably enjoy. 

“If I were to play some dubstep at Life’s a Beach or … like something that a lot of people [or] some people won’t like, and especially the person who hired me wouldn’t like, then I’m probably not going to get rehired,” Marques said.

One solution that student organizers are currently employing for smaller parties is curating playlists instead of hiring DJs.

Northington said at a recent Thursday Night Club (TNC) party hosted on CMC’s campus during the weekend of Halloween, several ASCMC events committee members — who he described as “a collection of people from different socioeconomic backgrounds, racial backgrounds, geographic backgrounds” — added songs to a collective playlist.

“It was a huge selection of music,” Northington said. “Some parties are fit for playlists, others are not. For TNC on Halloween, a playlist is great. It works.”

When asked about creating a playlist for a party in lieu of hiring a DJ, Yasu Agawa PO ’29 — a DJ himself — said that curating playlists doesn’t require the same creative skill that DJing does.

“Someone just using a playlist on their phone to play music is a waste — anyone can do it,” Agawa said. “Actually having a DJ that has creative skill and knows when and what to do in a crowd setting is better compared to some random person playing music. I feel like that defeats the whole purpose of this creative art with DJing.”

Northington said larger parties should still rely on DJs over playlists, but suggested that students from all backgrounds should pick up the DJing mantle themselves.

“If students are concerned with a lack of diversity in their music selection, I would suggest or recommend that they reach out to Table Manners,” Northington said. “Learn how to DJ. Have your friends learn how to DJ. Reach out to [the ASCMC events team] and we would love to have you.”

Facebook Comments
Exit mobile version