
If you are on Instagram, you’ve almost certainly seen this exact post: an American student studying abroad in Spain on a short trip to Morocco. They may be on a camel, a four-wheeler or doing a cartwheel in the sand, likely wearing a colorful pashmina wrapped around their head, with kohl lining their eyes.
Last year, my junior year, my Instagram feed was filled with such posts from high school friends, classmates and acquaintances. Students at universities across the United States take part in various study abroad programs during their undergraduate experience, frequently in European countries. Often, students choose these programs simply because they ‘sound cool,’ because they don’t require a language or because their friends are going there already. In other words, because they’re comfortable.
So every semester, American students flock to Europe to ‘become cultured’ in a foreign country. But when you choose a program that conveniently keeps you in your comfort zone, that experience is unlikely to reward you with the new understanding of the world and of yourself that is commonly associated with life abroad. You get a story to tell family and friends, but you do a grave disservice to yourself and everyone who has to work to provide you with a cushioned experience on your field trip.
Posts like the infamous Moroccan desert picture flatten all the complexities that have made it possible for one’s study abroad experience to exist in the first place: From visa accessibility to price and ever-changing border laws, study abroad programs are limited to a specific demographic of U.S.-born students who likely come from upper- or middle-class backgrounds. The tourism economy drives this demand; students seeking cultural experiences can now buy a commodified version of the culture of their choice, reducing entire countries’ traditions and histories to a student’s idea of a ‘cultural’ experience — in Spain, maybe, as well as on the common weekend trip to Morocco.
Nevertheless, when I saw those posts, I felt a twinge of jealousy. Admittedly, while I also posted Instagram snapshots of my experience, I intentionally joined a non-traditional study abroad program where we discussed issues around extractivism and capitalism. Like many other students choosing study abroad programs, I knew I wanted to go abroad but wasn’t sure where. I felt like this was a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity and did not want to regret the country that I chose. I wanted an experience that would give me access to places that would be harder to reach as an American college student, and I traveled with a human rights program to three different countries: Nepal, Jordan and Chile. I knew this program would challenge me mentally and physically, and that’s precisely why I chose it.
What I did not expect upon arriving in Nepal was that local students across the country had organized a social revolution driven by social media, inspired by anti-corruption protests in both Bangladesh and Sri Lanka. During these protests, the Nepali government turned its guns on the protesters and murdered 19 children. As international students, the cohort was instructed to shelter in place, while the rest of Kathmandu was placed under military curfew. Beyond the revolution, our coursework discussed immigration and border justice between India and Nepal, as well as menstrual justice movements in rural communities.
In Jordan, I spoke with indigenous communities in Petra facing persecution from the Jordanian government, along with generations of Palestinians who were displaced by and continue to be displaced by Israeli settlers in the ongoing genocide fueled by the United States. I met a woman named Ms. Amal, a single mother and member of the Bedouin tribe who grew up selling jewelry, kohl and pashminas to Petra’s tourists. We did not need a translator because Ms. Amal was fluent in the languages that are most commonly spoken by tourists: English, Spanish, Arabic and German. However, in the name of tourism, the Jordanian government had evicted the people native to Petra, the people whose ancestors created one of the seven wonders of the world that the government was now profiting off of. I learned all of this in a conversation facilitated by the Jordan program country coordinator, an experience that I was unlikely to have if I had just come to Petra as a regular tourist.
Lastly, in southern Chile, my cohort examined the effects of big agriculture on the Mapuche people and the forced disappearances and murders of the indigenous people, as well as post-dictatorship reconstruction after the Pinochet regime.
Now, I am not saying studying abroad necessarily means studying human rights, engaging directly in politics or visiting countries experiencing political upheaval. But at the very least, it should mean developing relationships and making an effort to participate in community life — to step outside of your comfort zone.
Through my time traveling, I wrestled with my own complicity in the culture economy and my responsibility to communities I knew little about. We, as American college students, have an urgent social responsibility to positively contribute to the people who are accepting us into their homes. My program allowed me to embed myself into communities through interacting with their members, from tribes in Petra to victims of the Pinochet regime’s political persecution, grounding me in local perspectives wherever I traveled.
My experience, however, contrasted with that of people who went on different, more traditional study abroad programs. I was excited to share our different experiences. I would get calls from my friends while they were on beaches in Portugal, exploring London or wandering around Copenhagen. Some took classes at centers for American students, surrounded by English speakers; they weren’t making an effort to learn the language of their host countries, understand the local culture or talk to local people. It was an American college transplanted to a tourist destination in Europe, and that seemed to be a common, even sought-after study abroad experience: the foreignness of a different country, made palatable by the comforts of American college life.
The Instagram post of the wealthy American student in a desert in Morocco represents the carelessness with which American students, who have access to a diverse range of countries across most continents, choose not to engage with the larger systems around them. They choose destinations because of the aesthetic appeal of being a ‘world traveler,’ and interact only with the people who can give them good stories, avoiding self-discovery, continuing to further their own narrative and developing no accountability to the community that they are supposedly studying abroad in. For example, popular bases for Claremont study abroad destinations often face gentrification and housing shortages. Though students may not be able to reverse these patterns on their own, a better understanding of the social and political factors within the spaces they inhabit is a prerequisite.
That said, I have also had friends who went on more traditional abroad trips in Europe, respectfully interacted with the cultures around them, learned languages and built meaningful connections with host families and locals. One does not need to go on a politics- or human-rights-themed program to understand their place in the country and world, along with the privileges they carry into the region. It means students must look at the diverse array of programs available to them, ideally with the goal of engaging thoughtfully with the communities around them and stepping outside their comfort zone. Plenty of programs will challenge you, whether that challenge be linguistic, social or political. Acknowledge the cultural structures operating in your home base, care about the communities that are being directly affected by them and go beyond the Instagram post.
There is no right way to study abroad, but my experience tells me you should always center on this question: How can I learn from and build community with the people around me?
Abby Lee SC ’27 spends so much time on social media that it has come to the point where she is writing Op-eds about it. The only two things she really likes are politics and going on her phone.
