Site icon The Student Life

OPINION: ‘Ali G: Who Iz I?’ makes the case for offensive satire in 2026

(Melinda Qerushi • The Student Life)

Sacha Baron Cohen’s films based on his numerous satirical characters — “Borat,” “Borat Subsequent Movie Film,” “Bruno,” “The Dictator” — have mainly garnered mixed-to-dissenting reviews among movie critics. Released last month, his new movie, “Ali G: Who Iz I?,” has not only taken the cake for his worst-received contemporary project, but is widely considered an utter failure at even achieving Baron Cohen’s usual goal of exposing “politicians or regimes.” 

Baron Cohen, a British comedian, got his start in “undercover comedy” with his character Ali G back in the 1990s. At a skatepark in London, Baron Cohen first realized people believed that Ali G — an “imbecile” dressed up as a caricature of a Black person — was real. After his boss threatened to fire him over this sketch, Baron Cohen said, “I knew I was onto something.” And he was right. 

Almost thirty years have passed since Ali G’s inception; it seems to me that a character who tricks people into exposing their own false beliefs and hateful inclinations should have no place in our society in 2026, as progress should march forward with time. Ali G instead reveals that this isn’t the case. In the Time article “Why Satire Is No Laughing Matter,” published in October, Baron Cohen acknowledges the outdatedness of Ali G’s character and cites it as the exact reason for his 2026 revival: “we have created an entire world where ignorance reigns and truth is inverted,” he said. Speaking about the film, Baron Cohen also likened the United States to an autocracy sustained by shared lies rather than shared truths. The world Ali G returns to is actually worse than it was 20 years ago.

“Da Ali G Show” has been dead since 2004, and critics question whether Ali G belongs in 2026, but I think they’re missing the point. Now more than ever, the character reveals just how little progress we have made in a country still steeped in dangerous misinformation.

The film does have some utterly indefensible moments that I cannot see the satirical purpose for, such as a lewd and racist AI apology video being shown to a room full of religious leaders, but does that automatically disqualify the film from being able to capture the severity of our enduring misinformation crisis? Baron Cohen recently said that the goal for the movie was to test if “conspiracies and lies … could turn intelligent people who believed in the theory of race replacement into murderers.” Thus, I see no choice but to call “Ali G: Who Iz I?” a success. 

Baron Cohen’s questionable choices don’t mean his experiment should be completely disregarded; in fact, I believe that’s exactly what the establishment wants.

In my various viewings of “Ali G: Who Iz I?,” I found four moments most emblematic of wider national phenomena that make the film worth talking about, and grant Ali G a shockingly fitting place in the 2026 zeitgeist. Two were scenes that tested the left, and two that tested the right. 

For the former, Baron Cohen cameos as his 2018 character, Dr. Nira Cain-N’Degeocello, a “self-hating white male,” who serves as a hypocritical left-wing virtue signaler. Dr. Nira is a walking contradiction: he wants to take down Ali G for being a cultural appropriator while being entirely one himself, claiming to “represent the entire Black community” and simultaneously spewing blatant misinformation, like insisting that ‘rap’ is an acronym for ‘Radical African Poetry.’

Dr. Nira appears at an Oakland Community Center meeting, where a member asks the attendees what change they want to see in their community: “affordable housing” and an end to how “every night, police kill Black people on camera,” they say. A moment later, Dr. Nira intrudes and tries to mobilize the room against Ali G’s cultural appropriation; they refuse, saying he is “a blazing, walking, three-dimensional example of [appropriation].” Baron Cohen tests the film’s hypothesis: whether lies may sway people into moral contradiction. 

Dr. Nira then recruits two white, male “progressive warriors” and mobilizes them, similarly, against Ali G’s cultural appropriation. Most shockingly, one recruit, Mitchell, makes no attempt to intervene while Dr. Nira ‘rapes’ Ali G to get his DNA and prove he isn’t Black. Ideological self-righteousness doesn’t immunize people against cruelty, as Baron Cohen demonstrates; it can actually launder extreme violence as a moral duty. The scene isn’t a real instance of sexual violence, as both characters are Baron Cohen, but Mitchell witnesses it as if it were, making no attempt to intervene. 

Later in the film, Ali G is offered a role in a TV show called “The Free Speech Show” by producer Karl Condello, which he claims is a “not left woke-type” show that is “on the other side” of the political aisle. The show features guest George Santos, former U.S. Representative and convicted fraudster, throwing mannequins dressed up as immigrants into gas chambers and mimicking the Elon Musk Nazi salute with the crowd while chanting “free speech.” Racial violence is repackaged as a respectable enactment of free speech against an anti-woke rebellion, one that Ali G ends up speaking against. “You is into increasing the hate,” he says. “[Your] message is whack! Me is into immigration … we all come from the same place innit? The punani.” Although communicated through an unserious and mocking vocabulary, Ali G is standing for truth. 

In the shocking finale of the film, Baron Cohen stages a militant anti-immigration training. He gets Michael Aboud, the Republican Party Chairman of El Paso County, and ex-pastor Joshua Loudermilk to kidnap Ali G’s pregnant partner, Julie, while she is seemingly in labor. The conspiracy theory that mobilizes the two men is insane: If Julie were to have her baby in the United States, then Ali G — whom they tell the men is the leader of El Salvador’s deadliest cartel, Los Chicos de Callejon — will have his 140,000 children become U.S. citizens. This conspiracy compels Aboud and Loudermilk to commit various felonies, kidnapping Julie and attempting to murder her newborn baby by dropping them from a lethal height. Yes, the two right-wingers think this is all real, and they are aware they are being filmed. Clearly, Aboud’s prejudice is fueled by misinformation, but the scene shows how conspiracies, once accepted as legitimate, can override both legal and moral restraint.

Through contradictions, political righteousness and violent acts of racism fueled by absurd misinformation, Baron Cohen reveals how Ali G does indeed have a place in 2026 as much as he did in the 90s. We have evidently made so little progress since 1998, when Ali G first interviewed the world, and he still has much to teach us in 2026 — perhaps now more than ever, given the discourse surrounding his satire’s relevance. If we discard Ali G’s message, as critics have done with “Ali G: Who Iz I?,” the lies will continue to prevail.

Elena Gutierrez PZ ’27 is a lover of comedy and specifically enjoys the art of improv.

Facebook Comments
Exit mobile version