Site icon The Student Life

Whoa there, UC Davis equestrian: A demotion isn’t discrimination

(Roy Shin • The Student Life)

In 2020, teenage equestrian champion Sophie Gochman called her own sport “an insular community with a gross amount of wealth and white privilege.” I know exactly what she meant. 

I have witnessed the dynamics that Gochman highlighted my entire life, from my first United States Equestrian Federation (USEF) Pony Finals, to my last United States Hunter-Jumper Association (USHJA) National Championships, to the day I set foot in the Intercollegiate Horse Shows Association (IHSA) arena as a collegiate equestrian. I transferred out of a top IHSA program partly because of the elitism and racism that run rampant in the equestrian community.

Recently, I’ve watched the UC Davis equestrian team become the face of athletic gender discrimination. In January 2026, UC Davis announced it would move its Division I equestrian team to club status and elevate STUNT, a sport built from cheerleading, to NCAA status. By summer, Keep Davis Riding, a coalition of riders, parents and alumni, had collected more than 41,000 signatures and raised $32,000 in hopes of reinstating the team. 

Current riders keep their scholarships through graduation, and the team lives on as a club. What they truly lost was NCAA status.

Four riders first sued in federal court, accusing the university of continuing to recruit them while it was already planning to cut the team. After that case was dismissed, 19 former riders filed a Title IX class action in September, arguing that UC Davis has shortchanged its female athletes on scholarship money for years. They are seeking nearly $1.4 million.

Grieving athletes have every right to fight for their team, but I don’t accept the story the Davis equestrians’ campaign tells: that equestrian athletes are victims of UC Davis’s discriminatory athletic scholarship practices, and that this injustice can be corrected by restoring the team to NCAA status. The campaign is driven by a community with enough money, connections and organizing power to hire lawyers and commission audits in order to fight to restore a team most students could never have joined.

College equestrian is overwhelmingly white, and it costs families tens of thousands of dollars a year on competition and horse maintenance bills before a rider ever reaches campus. A campaign driven by equestrian athletes shouldn’t borrow the language of discrimination without confronting the inequity within its own ranks, and the sport won’t deserve its place in college athletics until it does.         

Consider who reaches college riding in the first place. 

In my experience, a three-day show at the highest levels can cost $5,000 to $7,000, and many top riders compete for multiple weeks of the circuit with more than one horse. The Desert International Horse Park in Thermal, California, which ran 16 weeks of hunter/jumper competition last season, published fees that put stalls and entries alone above $30,000 for the entire circuit — before trainers, veterinarians, feed, farriers, travel and hotels.

Nationally, the sport’s makeup reflects who can afford it. Collegiate Consulting, the firm UC Davis hired to weigh the costs and benefits of its sports, found that the equestrian team’s 41 riders shared the equivalent of just 5.13 full scholarships, less than half the average at comparable NCAA programs. That works out to about an eighth of a scholarship per rider, which means most families are paying nearly all of tuition themselves. 

Furthermore, NCAA equestrian’s racial diversity is abysmal. White athletes make up about 61% of NCAA athletes overall, and equestrian is even more concentrated: in 2024-25, 1,244 of 1,418 NCAA equestrian riders, about 88%, were white. 

One UC Davis parent told CBS Sacramento that recruits spend their entire childhoods chasing an NCAA spot. I spent mine chasing one too. I have ridden and shown my whole life, and I competed at national levels before I ever applied to college. None of it was enough. 

After speaking with multiple NCAA coaches, teams and former riders during my college search, it became clear to me that I would not receive an offer because of my “lack of experience.” By that, they meant that I had not flown my horse across the country on Air Horse One to prestigious medal finals like the Maclay.

So I chose the IHSA, the club league that promises competition “regardless of riding level, gender, race, sexual orientation, or financial status.” In a way, it keeps that promise: riders compete on horses the host school provides, so no one needs to own a horse, and beginners can join. But because the IHSA is a club league, it offers no athletic scholarships. Those exist only on NCAA teams, and NCAA coaches recruit from the top shows, where a single circuit can cost $30,000 or more. 

So the sport’s scholarship money goes to riders whose families have already spent tens of thousands of dollars to compete. Riders who couldn’t afford the circuit can still join a club team, but they get no help paying for college.

Competing in this sport at any level takes privilege, and I had it. I grew up comfortable enough to own horses; I couldn’t have ridden at all otherwise. Even from there, I couldn’t keep up, and usually, skill wasn’t the difference. I rode alongside girls from some of the most recognizable families in the country, with wealth even I couldn’t dream of. There is so much money in the equestrian sport that even the rich can feel poor by comparison.

Title IX cuts both ways here. UC Davis added varsity equestrian in 2018 partly to meet Title IX, and replacing it with a larger STUNT team helps the university meet it now. The riders are citing Title IX too, but their new class action doesn’t ask to bring the team back; it claims UC Davis gave its female athletes less than their share of athletic aid. The lawsuit does point to a real problem. UC Davis’s own consultant counted 385 women and 273 men among its varsity athletes, nearly 60% women, yet women’s sports received just 56% of athletic aid.

That is money owed, but it’s a department-wide problem, not an equestrian one. The campaign’s other central accusation, that the university inflated equestrian’s costs, hasn’t held up either.

Now take a closer look at what’s replacing equestrian. USA Cheer created STUNT to give more than 500,000 high school cheerleaders a path to college competition. California is one of five states with high school STUNT programs, and participation has reportedly risen 80% since 2018. UC Davis projected a 50-member STUNT roster, more than the 41 riders it is replacing, and the NCAA granted STUNT championship status in January. The university didn’t need to inflate equestrian’s costs to make this case. The numbers favor STUNT on their own.

Most importantly, no one has to own a horse to try STUNT. For a young woman whose family could never afford a riding lesson, that is a real door into college.

None of this will convince the riders, parents and alumni fighting to save UC Davis’ team. They’ll point out that the class action seeks aid for all of the school’s female athletes, and that college riders draw their horses at random, so no one wins on a better horse. They’ll highlight that not every rider is wealthy; some families sacrifice enormously.

All of that can be true, and my argument stands. A random draw doesn’t decide who gets to the arena in the first place. Even the IHSA places new riders by how many blue ribbons they’ve won at USEF- or USHJA-rated shows, so the riders who start at the top are the ones whose families already paid for the competition circuit. 

If the lawsuit is about appropriate funding for all women athletes, it doesn’t need a team from a sport this wealthy and white as its face. Equestrian is an easy way for a university to meet Title IX because families invested in fancy ponies 10 years before their kids could even be recruited. Families who sacrifice everything to keep their daughters riding aren’t proof the sport is open. They’re proof of how high the barrier is. 

Inequity in collegiate equestrian isn’t just a UC Davis problem. The Claremont Colleges have their own IHSA team and also house two nationally ranked riders. Former 5C IHSA President Tyler St. Bernard PO ’20 wrote in 2020 that riding is expensive and therefore overwhelmingly white. Even US Equestrian’s CEO has admitted the federation “has not been a strong enough ally for Black equestrians.” 

The riders’ pain over their lost varsity status deserves merit, but we don’t deserve collegiate equestrian until it includes people who want to ride but can’t afford to. That work can start at colleges. IHSA teams could actively recruit students who have never ridden, push the colleges to fund their first lessons and gear, and partner with groups that bring riders of color into the sport. 

Club teams can provide an entry point for accessible riding, but the real responsibility lies with riders like me. For most of my riding life, I only looked up: at better riders, bigger fences and nicer horses. I never looked around to see who was missing. Teaching little kids finally made me look. Every one of them lights up the same way on a pony, and for every kid in my lesson, there are dozens who will never sit on one. 

Changing that doesn’t take a lawsuit. It takes riders bringing a friend to the barn, lending out boots and helmets, offering a free lesson and noticing who isn’t in the arena. 

To every rider: We are the lucky ones. Start acting like it.

Siena Giacoma PZ ’27 loves horses. Her barn door is open, and her spare boots are yours to borrow.

Facebook Comments
Exit mobile version